India Beheaded Pakistani Soldiers?

In India, Pakistan on January 16, 2013 at 10:23

There have been incursions and killing of Indian Soldiers by Pakistani‘s across the Line of Control(LoC).

Indian Army Chief confirmed the beading of an Indian soldier by the Pakistanis.

I am deliberately using the term Pakistanis instead of ‘Pakistani Armed Forces‘ as I am not sure whether this was the work of some elements of the Army and might not have had popular approval.

As in Life there are always two sides of a Story.

May be correct.

Pakistani Kills/beheads Indian Soldier

Pakistani Kills/beheads Indian Soldier

The point is if India had crossed the LoC ,and beheaded a Pakistani, why has not Pakistan come out publicly on this?

However there no denying the Fact that the Indian Electronic Media has become hysterical on this issue, especially The Times Now.

Retaliation by The Armed Forces is not  decided  in The Media  and I am sure the Government will do it its own way.

I am surprised at the interviews of serving generals in the Television Channels!

Read This from ‘The Hindu’

However, the officials who spoke to The Hindu had a very different account — of how a relatively innocuous incident spiralled into a series of murderous clashes, before culminating in the killing of Lance-Naik Sudhakar Singh and Lance-Naik Hemraj. Both armies, the officials said, engaged in aggressive action, driven by the still-fraught situation on the Line of Control.

Early in September, 70-year old Reshma Bi, left the village of Charonda, near Uri, to live with her sons and grandchildren across the Line of Control.

Ms. Reshma and her husband Ibrahim Lohar, a highly-placed military source said, had remained in Charonda after their sons crossed into Pakistan-administered Kashmir several years ago, to escape police investigations of their alleged role in cross-border trafficking. Police officers contacted by The Hindu said that Ms. Reshma appeared to have left in the hope of living out her last years with her family.

Ms. Reshma’s September 11 flight, a senior Srinagar-based military official said, set off alarms at the Uri-headquartered 19 infantry brigade. There, the incident was seen as highlighting vulnerabilities in defences along this stretch of the Line of Control. Charonda is located within metres of the Line of Control, outside of the three-layer counter-infiltration fencing which runs along the frontier.

Inside of a week after Ms. Reshma’s departure, troops of the 9 Maratha Light Infantry began constructing observations bunkers around Charonda, seeking to monitor the movement of villagers.

The construction work — barred by the terms of the Line of Control ceasefire which India and Pakistan agreed on in 2003 — provoked furious protests from Pakistani troops. Indian commanders, the military source said, conceded that the construction was in violation of the ceasefire.

However, they refused to stop work, arguing that the posts faced out towards the village, posing no threat to Pakistan. Early in October, the official said, tensions began to escalate. Pakistan even made announcements over a public address system, demanding that Indian troops end the construction work.

Following the announcement, shells followed. Pakistani troops fired mortar and high-calibre automatic weapons at Indian forward positions. The fire missed its intended target, but killed three villagers, 25-year-old Mohammad Shafi Khatana, 20-year-old Shaheena Bano, and a ninth-grade school student, Liaqat Ali. In the weeks leading up to the New Year, military sources said, hardly a week went by without occasional shots being fired at troops headed to the new observation posts.

Finally, on January 6, matters came to a head. Following a low-grade exchange of fire that night, 19 Infantry Division commander Gulab Singh Rawat sought and obtained permission for aggressive action against the Pakistani position from where his troops were being targeted.

Pakistan insists its post, Sawan Patra, was raided by Indian troops. India has denied the allegation. “None of our troops crossed the Line of Control,” said Jagdish Dahiya, an Indian army spokesperson.

Either way, though, a Pakistani soldier was dead before the shooting ended — and another critically injured..


For a start, both sides’ armies may have beheaded enemy corpses in tit-for-tat exchanges last year…

Indian troops, concerned about the ease with which she seemed to have crossed, started building bunkers around her village to keep a closer eye on residents. Pakistan viewed such a move so close to the frontier as a violation of a cease-fire agreement and tried to halt it by shelling and firing on the area. In October, three villagers were killed by Pakistani shelling, and on Jan. 6, an Indian brigadier general ordered raids on the Pakistani positions, the Hindu report said.

In a statement Thursday, the Indian army said “certain aspects” of the report were incorrect, specifically denying that its troops had crossed the border, known as the Line of Control, on Jan. 6. The army said it had instead carried out “controlled retaliation” for Pakistani cease-fire violations. It also said that the grandmother crossed the border in September 2011 and denied any link between that and recent events.



  1. One of the more rational and unbalanced posts. What we see by the media is nothing but sensationalism driven pseudo nationalism. Since, I watch ibn live,I was so put off by mr.sardesai’s biased arguments making us look like innocent victims, he completely refused to apply perspective to the uri district firing by the Indian army. Infact, most of the mayhem was purely driven by the media’s quest for trp’s.

    In the new year, sardesai’s started by saying that ibn live won’t stride for sensation ,but here, they were already doing it. Guess, it would be easier to get a dog straighten its tail.

    Like this

    • Sardesai would seem most meek if you watch Arnab Gosawami screaming for Blood in TimesNow.

      Yesterday he had his measure when Pirzada,Jilani and foreign Ministers of Pakistan hot him hard.

      Though I do not agree with Pakistan’s moves , deciding Foreign policy on Media is ridiculous.

      Please read some of my blogs on Arnab Goswami,TimesNow and also check out the ownership pattern of these ‘Indian Media’

      Like this

    • I think the word ‘Unbalanced’ might read as ‘balanced” Or ‘unbiased’
      Is it?

      Like this

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,423 other followers

%d bloggers like this: